A bowl of unadon, glazed grilled eel over white rice
|

Unagi in Japan: Kanto or Kansai, Hitsumabushi, Doyo no Ushi and the Eel Houses Worth the Wait

The cutting board at Kawatoyo Honten sits right on the street, a single slab of ginkgo about three metres long and thirty centimetres thick, and the man behind it does not look up. A live eel goes down, a steel spike pins its head to the wood, and a short Edo-style blade opens it from the back in one long pull. Moments later the fillet is on a skewer and the next eel is already on the board, while the queue for lunch shuffles past on its way up the approach to Naritasan Shinshoji.

Kawatoyo Honten, a three-storey wooden eel restaurant on Naritasan Omotesando in Narita, Chiba
Kawatoyo Honten on the Narita temple approach. The splitting board faces the street on purpose: the shop calls it an open kitchen, and the cooks at it have been splitting eels for decades. Take a numbered ticket from the machine at the door, then go and see the temple while the numbers tick down. Photo by Miyuki Meinaka / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

Most people who fly into Narita never see this street. It is eleven minutes on foot from JR Narita or Keisei Narita station, about twenty minutes from the airport by car, and the family behind Kawatoyo has been dealing in eel here for more than a century. Kawatoyo’s own history starts in 1910 with a family of river fishermen and eel wholesalers on Inba-numa and the Tone River, and its founder taught his methods to other cooks on the approach. That is a large part of why Narita became an eel town at all.

I came for the unaju and stayed for the ritual. Unagi is the one Japanese meal where the waiting is part of the dish: the eel is split, steamed and grilled to order, a tare that has been topped up for generations goes on in coats, and the whole thing arrives in a lacquered box that steams when you lift the lid. At Kawatoyo the plain unaju, two-thirds of an eel, is ¥3,200. A whole eel is ¥4,300.

Unaju with grilled eel over rice in a lacquered box at Kawatoyo Honten in Narita
Kawatoyo’s unaju, lid off. Grades here are measured in eel rather than in poetic names: two-thirds of a fish, one fish, or one and a half. The sauce is already on the rice, but there is a jug of extra tare on every table for people who want more. Photo by Miyuki Meinaka / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

This guide is about where that box comes from, why it tastes different in Tokyo and Osaka, how to eat hitsumabushi in Nagoya without looking lost, and which eel houses are worth the queue. It also gets into the part nobody puts on the menu: the Japanese eel is an endangered species, and what you order matters a little.

The Naritasan Omotesando approach street lined with old wooden shops in Narita, Chiba
Naritasan Omotesando, early in the day. The approach runs downhill from the station to the temple gate, so the walk back up after a heavy eel lunch is the harder half. Kawatoyo starts serving at 10:00, and the first hour is the quietest. Photo by Perry Li / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 2.0)
A cook grilling skewered eel over charcoal at a Japanese market stall
Eel on the grill, the way most people first meet it. Skewered fillets sold from a market counter are the street version of a meal that eel houses take an hour over. They’re fine as a snack, but the texture of eel that was alive that morning is something else.

What unagi actually is

Unagi is the Japanese freshwater eel, Anguilla japonica. It hatches far out in the Pacific, west of the Mariana Islands, where a Japanese research team led by the fisheries scientist Katsumi Tsukamoto finally pinned down the spawning grounds in 2006. The larvae drift back towards East Asia on the currents, turn into transparent glass eels about five centimetres long, and swim up rivers in Japan, China, Korea and Taiwan to grow.

Nineteenth-century scientific illustration of the Japanese eel, Anguilla japonica
The Japanese eel, drawn in 1856. This plate comes from an American report on Japanese fishes made after Commodore Perry’s expedition. The fish itself has not changed; what has changed is that almost none of the eels in Japanese restaurants today grew up in a river.

Nearly every eel you’ll eat in Japan is farmed, but not bred. Nobody has made commercial full-cycle eel farming work yet, so every farm still starts with wild glass eels caught at river mouths in winter and early spring, raised in heated ponds for six months to a year or more. The state fisheries research agency managed the full cycle in a laboratory in 2010, and that is still a lab result rather than something you can buy.

The other thing to know: you never eat unagi raw. Eel blood contains a toxin that heat destroys, which is why there is no eel sashimi on a normal menu and why everything below involves fire.

Kabayaki and shirayaki

Kabayaki is the classic preparation, and the word covers most of what you’ll see. The eel is split open, boned, skewered flat on bamboo, grilled, and basted with tare, a sauce of soy sauce and mirin with sugar or sake depending on the house. The name probably comes from the old way of cooking eel whole on a vertical skewer, which looked like the brown seed head of a cattail, gama. Edo-period writers argued about that even then, and a rival theory points to the colour of birch bark.

Glossy kabayaki eel fillets on a plate
Kabayaki, the glossy one. The shine is layers of tare caramelised over charcoal, applied and grilled several times. Good kabayaki should smell of char and soy before you see it.

The tare is the thing eel houses are proudest of. Most keep one pot going for decades and top it up rather than start fresh, so it slowly picks up fat and juices from every eel dipped in it. Some houses also grill the heads and drop them into the pot. Ask any old eel house how old its sauce is and you will get a founding date as the answer.

Shirayaki is the same eel grilled with no sauce at all. You eat it with wasabi and a little soy, or with grated daikon, and it is the clearest test of a kitchen because there is nothing to hide behind. If an eel house does a good shirayaki, order one to share before the main box.

Shirayaki, eel grilled without sauce, served with wasabi and soy at a Tokyo eel house
Shirayaki with wasabi and soy. Without tare, the eel’s own fat does all the work, so this is where the difference between a good eel and an average one shows up. At the old houses I checked, shirayaki costs the same as kabayaki of the same size, or more. Photo by City Foodsters / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)

From cattail skewers to Edo-mae

Eel has been on Japanese plates far longer than sushi. The poet Otomo no Yakamochi teases a skinny friend in the eighth-century Man’yoshu anthology, telling him eel is good for summer weight loss and he should go and catch some. A second poem tells him not to drown doing it. For most of the following thousand years, eel was something you chopped up, skewered and grilled with miso or salt.

Painted portrait of the poet Otomo no Yakamochi by Kano Tan'yu
Otomo no Yakamochi, eel’s first critic. This 1648 portrait by the painter Kano Tan’yu shows the poet as one of the Thirty-Six Immortals of Poetry. His eel poems are jokes at a friend’s expense, which tells you eel was a health food long before it was a treat.

Edo changed that. The drained marshes and canals of the new shogun’s city filled with eels, and stalls sold them grilled on skewers for about 16 mon, roughly the price of a bowl of soba. Once dark Kanto soy sauce from Noda and Choshi and sweet mirin spread through the city, the split, boned, sauced kabayaki took shape. Before sushi took the name, “Edo-mae” meant eel from the water in front of the city.

The rice bowl came last. The usual story credits Okubo Imasuke, a backer of the Nakamura-za theatre in Edo, who had grilled eel sandwiched between hot rice so it stayed warm on the way to the playhouse, sometime in the Bunka era (1804–1818). Another writer remembered unadon on sale in the next street when he was a boy, so the fair summary is that several people had the same idea. If you want the wider story of how Edo ate, from street soba to sushi stalls, my history of Japanese food covers it.

Edo-period screen painting by Hishikawa Moronobu showing the Nakamura-za kabuki theatre and its crowds
The Nakamura-za, painted by Hishikawa Moronobu. This late seventeenth-century screen shows the theatre district where, a century later, eel on rice is supposed to have been invented as a takeaway for the playhouse. Kabuki audiences ate through day-long programmes, so food that stayed hot was worth paying for.

Kanto or Kansai: the split that decides your eel

Japan has two schools of eel, and they disagree at almost every step. In the Kanto style of Tokyo, the eel is split down the back, grilled plain, steamed, then sauced and grilled again. In the Kansai style of Osaka and Kyoto, it is split down the belly and grilled straight through with the sauce, no steaming at all, a method called jiyaki.

Kanto-style unaju with soft steamed eel in a lacquered box in Kanda, Tokyo
Kanto style: soft enough to cut with chopsticks. This unaju from an old shop in Kanda shows the Tokyo result: plump, evenly glazed and soft all the way through from the steaming. The skin is tender rather than crisp, which is exactly what Tokyo eaters want. Photo by yuiseki aoba / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)
Kanto (Tokyo) Kansai (Osaka, Kyoto)
Split Down the back (sebiraki) Down the belly (harabiraki)
Cooking Grilled plain, steamed, then sauced and grilled Grilled with sauce from raw, no steaming
Texture Soft, almost melting, less fatty Crisp skin, firmer flesh, richer fat
Local name for the bowl Unadon or unaju Mamushi (Osaka), often with eel inside the rice too
The head Taken off before grilling Traditionally left on while it grills
Where to taste it Tokyo, Narita Osaka; Nagoya grills unsteamed too

Everybody tells you the same story about the split. Edo was a city of samurai, so cutting a fish open from the belly looked too much like seppuku, while Osaka merchants liked the idea of “opening the belly” and speaking frankly. It’s a good story. It is also probably folklore, because Edo cooks split every other fish down the belly without a second thought.

The likelier reason is mechanical. A belly-split eel has its thin edges on the outside, and when it is steamed those edges split and fall off the skewers; a back-split eel keeps the thick side outermost and survives the steamer. A mature eel’s dorsal fin is also tough, and cutting from the back takes it out cleanly. Watanabe Zenjiro’s history of how Edo built Japanese cuisine dates back-splitting as the Edo norm only to the Bunsei era (1818–1830), once steaming had arrived to soften the fattier, muddier eels of the Kanto marshes.

Osaka-style eel over rice, called mamushi, at Honke Shibato in Koraibashi, Osaka
Mamushi at Honke Shibato, Osaka. The shop has been grilling Kansai-style since the Kyoho era (1716–1736), which puts it among the oldest eel houses in Japan. Mamushi has nothing to do with the snake of the same name; one theory traces it to rice steamed with the eel tucked inside it. Photo by 南宮博士 / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 2.0)

Neither school wins outright, and you should try both. Kanto eel is the gentler of the two: the steaming draws out fat, so a whole box goes down easily. Kansai eel is louder, with crackling skin, firmer flesh and the full weight of the fat, and because it holds together without steaming, Osaka’s mamushi often keeps the old habit of hiding a second layer of eel inside the rice. I lean Kanto for an unaju and Kansai for anything eaten in pieces.

The line is blurrier than the table makes it look. Hamamatsu and the area around Lake Suwa in Nagano grill a back-split eel without steaming it, and much of Kyushu does the same, grilling it longer and darker. Nagoya grills its eel unsteamed, the Kansai way.

And one of the most famous eel houses in Kyoto, Kyogoku Kaneyo, grills the Edo way: back-split, plain-grilled, steamed, then sauced. It says so right on its menu.

Eel over rice in a box with pickles and soup at a restaurant in Sekigahara, Gifu
An eel box in Sekigahara. The small town on the old road between Nagoya and Kyoto is better known for the battle of 1600. Anywhere along this stretch, it’s worth asking how your eel was split and whether it was steamed; staff are usually happy to explain.

The bowls, and which to order

Once the eel is grilled, what you order is mostly a question of container. Unadon is eel on rice in a round bowl. Unaju is the same thing in a square lacquered box, a jubako. At shops that sell both, the box usually carries more eel and comes with soup and pickles, so it sits higher on the menu, but the eel inside is the same.

A bowl of unadon, glazed grilled eel over white rice
Unadon in its round bowl. Before the box took over, the bowl was the standard, and in the Meiji era “unagi donburi” got shortened to unadon. A good one has sauce in the rice all the way to the bottom.

Ranks on an eel menu are almost always about quantity. “Jo” and “tokujo” mean more eel, not better eel, because a shop normally buys from one supplier; if a house is serving eels from two different regions or a premium brand, the menu says so separately. Read the small print for the number of pieces or the fraction of a fish, and order the size you’ll actually finish.

Hitsumabushi: one bowl, three ways

Nagoya’s eel dish is hitsumabushi: Kansai-style eel, crisp from the grill, cut into strips and laid over rice in a wooden tub, the ohitsu, with a tray of condiments and a pot of dashi or green tea. The idea is that you eat the same eel three different ways, and the order matters.

Hitsumabushi, chopped grilled eel on rice in a wooden tub, at Atsuta Horaiken in Nagoya
Hitsumabushi at Atsuta Horaiken. The 1873 restaurant registered the hiragana name as a trademark in 1987, though the dish itself is now served all over Japan. Its own explanation for the tub is practical: delivery staff kept breaking the old ceramic bowls on the way back, so they switched to wood. Photo by Bariston / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)
  • First quarter, plain. Score the rice into quarters with the paddle, scoop one into your small bowl and eat it as it comes.
  • Second quarter, with condiments. Add chopped green onion, wasabi and shredded nori, and mix.
  • Third quarter, as a soup. Add the condiments again, then pour over the hot dashi or tea so it becomes a kind of eel ochazuke.
  • Last quarter, your favourite. Most people go back to the dashi, and Atsuta Horaiken’s own instructions say to do whichever you liked best.

The third stage is the one people skip and shouldn’t. The broth softens the crisp edges of the eel and the rice soaks up the tare, and it is the best argument for eating eel Nagoya-style.

Two Nagoya shops claim the dish: Atsuta Horaiken dates it to the Meiji era, while Ibasho in Nishiki, founded in 1909, dates its own version to the Taisho era. A 1964 Nagoya food guide already lists hitsumabushi under Ibasho, and a shop in Tsu in Mie Prefecture has its own story about chopped staff meals of tough wild eel. Nobody will settle it, and that’s fine.

A hitsumabushi set with a tub of chopped eel over rice, condiments and broth
The full hitsumabushi tray. Small bowl, paddle, condiments and the broth pot. If the broth comes as tea rather than dashi, the third round is lighter and slightly bitter; I prefer dashi, but plenty of Nagoya regulars swear by tea.

Yanagawa’s seiro-mushi

In Yanagawa, a canal town south of Fukuoka, the eel goes into a steamer. For seiro-mushi, rice is mixed with tare and steamed in a small lacquered basket, topped with fresh kabayaki and a nest of thin-sliced omelette, kinshi tamago, and steamed again. The result is softer and sweeter than any bowl in Tokyo, with the sauce all the way through the rice.

Yanagawa seiro-mushi, eel and shredded egg over rice steamed in a lacquered basket
Seiro-mushi, Yanagawa’s eel. The yellow egg ribbons are not decoration; the dish isn’t seiro-mushi without them. Because it has been steamed twice, the eel here is the softest you’ll find anywhere in Japan. Photo by Sakaori / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 3.0)

Ganso Motoyoshiya claims to have invented it, in the first year of Tenna, 1681, and says it has kept the founder’s sauce going ever since. Its main shop on Asahimachi serves a plain seiro-mushi for ¥4,800 and a larger one for ¥5,200, both with liver soup and pickles. It opens 10:30–19:30 (last orders 19:00) and closes on Mondays.

Kyoto’s kinshi-don and the other bowls

Kyoto’s best-known eel bowl is the kinshi-don at Kyogoku Kaneyo, and it looks like a mistake the first time. A rolled omelette the size of the bowl covers the eel completely, so all you see is a yellow lid. Underneath is Edo-style eel on sauced rice, and the light, dashi-soaked egg is the Kyoto part.

Kinshi-don at Kyogoku Kaneyo in Kyoto, a thick rolled omelette covering eel over rice
Kinshi-don at Kyogoku Kaneyo, Shinkyogoku. Lift the omelette before you start or you’ll eat all the egg first. The standard size is ¥3,000, slightly cheaper than the plain eel bowl, and the building’s interior has hardly changed since the Taisho era.

Kaneyo is on Rokkaku-dori, just off the Shinkyogoku covered arcade, about five minutes on foot from Kyoto Shiyakusho-mae station on the Tozai line. It opens 11:30–15:30 and 17:00–20:30, is closed on Wednesdays and on Tuesday evenings, and the upstairs tatami room hosts a monthly rakugo comedy night. If you’re planning a whole day of eating in the city, my guide to what to eat in Kyoto has the rest of it, including hamo, the bony pike conger that Kyoto eats in summer instead.

The covered Shinkyogoku shopping arcade in central Kyoto
Shinkyogoku, Kyoto. The covered arcade is mostly souvenir shops and cheap eats now. Turn east onto Rokkaku-dori by the cinema and look for the lanterns of Kaneyo.

Beyond these, eel turns up in smaller forms too.

Umaki is a rolled omelette wrapped around a strip of kabayaki. Uzaku is kabayaki with sliced cucumber in vinegar. Unagi chazuke is leftover eel with tea poured over rice. And the station lunchbox, unagi bento, is a classic of the Tokaido line, especially at Hamamatsu.

Slices of umaki, a rolled omelette wrapped around grilled eel
Umaki, eel in an omelette. The egg is made with dashi, so it’s soft and slightly sweet around the sauced eel. It’s the easiest starter to share while the main eel is still on the grill. Photo by Zheng Zhou / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)
Unagi chazuke, grilled eel on rice with tea poured over
Unagi chazuke. Eel, rice, shredded nori, mitsuba and a dab of wasabi, finished with hot tea or broth. It’s essentially the third round of hitsumabushi served on its own. Photo by Kossy@FINEDAYS / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)

Doyo no Ushi no Hi: the summer eel day

On one or two days every summer, the whole country eats eel. Doyo no Ushi no Hi is the “ox day” of the summer doyo, the eighteen-odd days before the start of autumn in the traditional almanac, when days are counted off against the twelve zodiac animals. In 2027 it falls twice, on 21 July and 2 August. Supermarkets put out eel stands, convenience stores take pre-orders for eel bento, and the famous shops get queues around the block.

Portrait of the Edo polymath Hiraga Gennai from an 1899 biography
Hiraga Gennai, the man usually given the credit. The scientist, writer and inventor died in 1780 with a long list of real achievements. The eel slogan may not be one of them: nobody has found an Edo source for the story.

The story everybody tells involves Hiraga Gennai, an Edo inventor and writer. An eel seller whose business died every summer asked him for help, and he told him to put up a sign reading “today is the day of the ox”.

There was an old belief that eating something beginning with “u” on ox day protected you from the summer heat, so the eel shop did a roaring trade and every other eel shop copied it. A neat story, but nobody has traced it to an Edo source. An 1822 miscellany of city gossip dates the eel habit to the 1770s and 1780s without mentioning Gennai at all.

Other “u” foods have mostly faded, though one survives on your tray. The slice of pickled melon, narazuke, that comes with an eel box is a leftover of the custom of eating uri, gourds and melons, on ox day. Udon and umeboshi were on the list too.

Pieces of narazuke, vegetables pickled in sake lees, on display at a pickle shop
Narazuke, the leftover “u”. Gourd and other vegetables pickled for months in sake lees turn dark brown and taste faintly of alcohol. The slice beside your eel box is a small survival of the ox-day custom of eating uri. Photo by daveyll / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 2.0)

Here is the part that surprises people: summer isn’t when eel is best. Wild eels fatten up in late autumn and early winter before going back to sea, and that’s when their flesh is richest. Farmed eel is fairly steady all year, which makes the summer rush mostly a habit.

A few top houses refuse to play along: Nodaiwa in Tokyo closes on Doyo no Ushi no Hi rather than serve eel it isn’t happy with. My advice is to skip the day itself. The same shop, a week later, is calmer, the cooks aren’t rushed, and nobody will hurry you out.

A packaged kabayaki eel fillet in a supermarket tray
The supermarket kabayaki. This is what most of Japan actually eats on ox day: pre-grilled, sauced fillets reheated at home. They’re fine on rice, but check the label for the country of origin and, if you can, the species.

The eel towns

Every region claims good eel, but a handful of towns have built their identity on it. They are spread along the old Tokaido road and down into Kyushu, and most are easy day trips from a big city.

Hamamatsu and Lake Hamana

“Eel means Hamamatsu” is how the city puts it, and the reason is farming. More than 120 years ago, in the Meiji era, a man named Hattori Kurajiro started raising eels in ponds by Lake Hamana, and the lake had everything a farm needed: glass eels in the estuary, a mild climate, flat land for ponds, plenty of groundwater, and cheap feed from the lake’s small fish and from the silkworms of the local silk industry.

Eel farm ponds beside Lake Hamana with the Tokaido Shinkansen embankment in the distance
Eel ponds by Lake Hamana. The Tokaido Shinkansen runs right past the old farm ponds on a raised embankment, so you’ve probably seen eel farms without knowing it. The ponds today are mostly covered with plastic greenhouses that keep the water around 30°C. Photo by Dr.yellow / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

Glass eels are still caught from December to April at the mouth of the lake and of the Tenryu River, then raised in greenhouse ponds on water drawn from 300 metres underground. Sitting halfway between Tokyo and Osaka, Hamamatsu also serves both styles of eel, which makes it the best place to taste them side by side. Atsumi, in business since 1907 and about five minutes’ walk from Hamamatsu Station, grills Kanto-style; it closes on Tuesdays and Wednesdays and serves until the day’s eel runs out.

The Unagi Pie Factory production floor in Hamamatsu, Shizuoka
Where unagi pie is made. Shunkado has sold this crisp pastry since 1961, modelled on a French palmier, with eel extract in the dough and a sweet glaze brushed on like kabayaki. It doesn’t taste of eel. The slogan “a snack for the night” was meant to suggest family time in the evening, which is not how most people read it. Photo by ajari / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)

Hamamatsu’s other food claim to fame is dumplings, and the city’s long-running fight with Utsunomiya over who eats the most is a whole story of its own in my gyoza guide. If you’re only changing trains, the eel bento at Hamamatsu Station is the classic stand-in.

Nagoya

Nagoya is hitsumabushi country, and the two names to know are the two that claim to have invented it. Atsuta Horaiken’s main restaurant, the Jinya, is seven minutes on foot from Atsuta Jingu Temmacho station on the Meijo subway line. It opens 11:30–14:00 and 16:30–20:30 (last orders), is closed on Wednesdays and the second and fourth Thursday, and charges ¥4,950 for hitsumabushi or ¥6,600 for the one-and-a-half portion.

Its Jingu branch sits just outside the south gate of Atsuta Jingu, three minutes from the same station, so you can combine the shrine with lunch.

The entrance to Atsuta Jingu shrine in Nagoya
Atsuta Jingu, a few minutes from the eel. One of the most important Shinto shrines in Japan sits in a big wooded precinct in southern Nagoya. Visit before lunch; the Horaiken branch by the south gate gets long queues at weekends.

That branch closes on Tuesdays and the second and fourth Monday. On busy days the restaurant warns that it may stop taking names before the official last order.

Ibasho is the counterweight. It has been one family business since 1909, burned down in the 1945 air raids, and moved into its current building in Nishiki 3-chome in 1952; it now runs a single shop, about five minutes on foot from Sakae station, and says firmly that it has no branches. Hitsumabushi here is ¥3,870, with a layer of shredded nori under the eel. It’s cash only and closed on Sundays and the second and third Monday.

Mishima

Mishima, on the Tokaido Shinkansen at the foot of Mount Fuji, has a good claim to the best eel in Japan, and the reason is water. Rain and snow that fall on Fuji take years to filter through the lava and come up as springs all over town, cold and clean, and Mishima eel houses keep their eels in it before cooking.

The spring-fed Genbei River with stepping stones in Mishima, Shizuoka
The Genbei River, Mishima. This stream runs through the middle of town on water from Fuji’s springs, and you can walk along stepping stones in it. The same cold groundwater sits under the eel houses a few streets away.

Sakuraya, on Hirokoji-cho, rests its eels for three to four days in cold spring water drawn up from underground. The shop’s explanation is that it takes away the muddy smell, trims the fat to the right level and firms up the flesh. The result is eel that feels oddly light for how big the portion is. A one-eel unaju is ¥5,500.

Sakuraya, which dates to 1856, opens 11:00–20:00 and closes when the eel runs out, with a possible break from 15:30 to 17:00 while the cooks prepare. It’s closed on Wednesdays, plus one Tuesday-Wednesday pair a month. Go at opening, or expect to queue.

Narita

Narita is the easiest eel town to reach and the one most people skip. The approach to Naritasan Shinshoji, the big Shingon temple, has a long run of eel restaurants, many of them in old wooden buildings, and on a still day you smell the charcoal before you see the shops.

Kawatoyo Honten is the one with the cutting board on the street. It opens 10:00–17:00 (last orders) with no regular day off, takes no bookings for groups under ten, and accepts only cash or PayPay. On the ground floor you buy a meal ticket first; upstairs you pay at the end. If you have a long layover or an early afternoon flight, this is a better use of three hours than the departure lounge.

A visitor in front of a pagoda at Naritasan Shinshoji temple in Narita
Naritasan Shinshoji. The temple grounds are huge, with several pagodas, halls and a park behind them, so you can easily fill the wait for an eel ticket here. Kawatoyo’s ticket numbers can be checked on its website while you walk round.

Yanagawa

Yanagawa is an old castle town crossed by canals, about fifty minutes south of Fukuoka’s Tenjin on the Nishitetsu line, and most people come for the punt-boat ride. The boats drift past willows and under bridges so low the passengers have to duck.

A punt boat on the canals of Yanagawa, Fukuoka
The Yanagawa canals. The boatmen pole the punts by hand along the old castle moats. Do the boat first and eat after; seiro-mushi is too heavy to sit through a ride on. Photo by Asturio Cantabrio / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

The town’s eel was famous long before the boats were. Motoyoshiya’s main shop is on Asahimachi in an old wooden building, and it also runs a branch in Okinohata, the riverside district, plus a counter in the Iwataya department store in Tenjin. Other Yanagawa eel houses serve seiro-mushi too, but if you’re only eating one, it makes sense to eat it at the place that claims to have invented it.

The thatched entrance of Ganso Motoyoshiya, an eel restaurant in Yanagawa, Fukuoka
Ganso Motoyoshiya, Yanagawa. “Ganso” means “the original”, and the shop has been using the word for a long time. It’s open 10:30–19:30 and closed on Mondays; if Monday is a public holiday, it closes the next day instead. Photo by Asturio Cantabrio / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

Osaka and Kyoto

Osaka’s food reputation leans on its griddles, the okonomiyaki and takoyaki of the Osaka street food circuit, but it has the oldest Kansai eel. Honke Shibato, open since the Kyoho era and now on its fifteenth generation, is in Koraibashi, three minutes on foot from Yodoyabashi station on the Midosuji line. It’s open 11:00–14:00 and 17:00–20:30 and closed on Sundays and public holidays.

Order the mamushi. The Kansai jiyaki eel arrives crisp at the edges, with a second layer of eel inside the rice, and it’s the dish to compare against a Tokyo unaju. Kyoto’s Kaneyo, back-split and steamed, is the reverse surprise, so if you’re doing both cities, do one of each.

Tokyo’s old eel houses

Tokyo has hundreds of eel restaurants and a small group of old ones that set the standard. They are all Kanto-style, they all take their time, and they’re spread across the city rather than clustered, so pick one by neighbourhood. My guide to Tokyo’s food neighbourhoods will help you plan the rest of the day around whichever you choose.

Nodaiwa, Higashi-Azabu

Nodaiwa is the name most Tokyo eel lovers give first. The main shop in Higashi-Azabu dates to the Edo period, is run by the fifth generation of the Kanemoto family, and holds a Michelin star. The eel is steamed slowly to take off the excess fat, and the sauce is kept and adjusted rather than replaced.

The old wooden frontage of the eel restaurant Nodaiwa in Higashi-Azabu, Tokyo
Nodaiwa’s frontage in Higashi-Azabu. The old storehouse-style building sits on a corner among modern blocks, about five minutes from Akabanebashi station. Nodaiwa has also run a branch on rue Saint-Honoré in Paris since 1996, so you can try it in Paris before you fly. Photo by Koichi Suzuki / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)

It’s about five minutes on foot from Akabanebashi station on the Oedo line, or seven from exit 2 of Kamiyacho on the Hibiya line. Hours are 11:00–13:30 and 17:00–20:00, with lunch running to 14:00 on Saturdays. It’s closed on Sundays and, as above, on Doyo no Ushi no Hi. Expect a service charge on top of the menu price.

Komagata Maekawa, Asakusa

Maekawa started out as a river-fish wholesaler and turned into an eel restaurant in the Bunka-Bunsei era, about 220 years ago. Customers used to arrive by boat on the Sumida River; now the dining room looks across the river to the Tokyo Skytree. The composer Kosaku Yamada once described its eel as having “a delicate taste like chamber music”, and the shop still quotes him.

The eel restaurant Komagata Maekawa beside the Sumida River in Asakusa, Tokyo
Komagata Maekawa from the street. The plain front hides the view: the dining rooms face the Sumida River, so the window seats are the ones to ask for. It’s a minute from exit A2 of Asakusa station on the Toei Asakusa line. Photo by Kentin / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

A standard unaju with domestic farmed eel is ¥6,300. Maekawa also serves Bando Taro, a branded farmed eel raised on a fish-paste feed to taste closer to wild eel, from ¥7,800. It’s open 11:30–21:00 (last orders 20:30) with a 10% service charge after 16:00. One more detail I liked: the shop no longer serves wild Japanese eel at all, because of its endangered status.

Izuei, Ueno

Izuei says it began as one of the simple eel stalls that lined the streets around Ueno in Edo times, and its main restaurant is still there, five minutes on foot from the Shinobazu exit of JR Ueno station. It’s the most practical of the old houses if you’re spending a day in Ueno Park.

The main restaurant of the eel house Izuei in Ueno, Tokyo
Izuei’s main restaurant in Ueno. The old stall is long gone; the main shop is now a multi-storey building near Shinobazu Pond, with private rooms upstairs. Izuei also runs a branch inside Ueno Park itself. Photo by Kentin / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

Izuei is also the place that shows how little the grade names mean. Its menu runs matsu (pine), take (bamboo), ume (plum): unaju is ¥3,960, ¥5,060 and ¥6,160 in that order. Pine is the smallest.

At most other shops pine is the top of the range. Always read the fraction or the price, never the tree.

Obana, Minami-Senju

Obana is the cult one. It’s about five minutes on foot from Minami-Senju station, takes no cards, and serves until the eel runs out. People start queuing well before the 11:30 opening, and the wait after you sit down is long because everything is cooked from scratch.

The gated entrance of Obana eel restaurant in Minami-Senju, Tokyo
Obana’s gate in Minami-Senju. There is a tiny shrine and a red torii in the courtyard, a reminder that eel houses traditionally hold memorial services for the eels they cook. Photo by City Foodsters / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)
Unaju at Obana, an eel restaurant in Minami-Senju, Tokyo
Obana’s unaju. Classic Tokyo eel, steamed soft and lacquered dark, filling the box from edge to edge. Bring cash, and bring something to read for the wait. Photo by City Foodsters / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)

The cheap end

You don’t need to spend ¥6,000. The Unagi no Naruse chain, which has spread fast across the country, sells Japanese eel in three sizes: half an eel for ¥1,900, three-quarters for ¥2,500 and a whole eel for ¥2,900. Here the pine is the biggest, which makes the Izuei point for you.

Unaju from the Unagi no Naruse chain, matsu size with a whole eel
A Naruse matsu box. At ¥2,900 for a whole eel, it’s less than half what the old houses charge. The eel is perfectly decent; what you lose is the charcoal and the decades-old sauce.

Below that, the beef bowl chains bring out eel every spring and summer. Sukiya launched its 2026 season in April with a regular unadon at ¥980. It’s a thin slice of eel on a lot of rice, and it does the job if you’re curious, but it isn’t the same dish as anything above.

A budget unadon from the Sukiya beef bowl chain
The ¥980 option. Beef bowl chain unadon is a thin fillet over a lot of rice. Fine for a quick lunch, but it’s no guide to what eel can be.

Ordering, waiting and what comes on the side

At a proper eel house, the eel is killed, split and cooked after you order, and that takes time. Thirty minutes is common, and longer at busy places. The Edo line was that hurrying an eel house is yabo, uncool, and that you should drink sake with the pickles while you wait. The old houses still expect exactly that.

Old eel cooks have a saying, “three years to skewer, eight years to split, a lifetime to grill”, and that time on the grill is what you’re waiting for. Order a drink and a starter as soon as you sit down. Sake is the classic match; my guide to drinking sake in Japan explains how to order it if you’re not sure where to start.

Skewers of grilled eel liver, kimoyaki
Kimoyaki, the cook’s snack. Grilled eel liver with tare, bitter and chewy. Each eel has one liver, and many shops send them all to the soup first, so kimoyaki is often limited or sold out. It eats a lot like a yakitori skewer of offal. Photo by Kossy@FINEDAYS / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)

The sides are part of the meal. Kimosui is a clear broth with the eel’s liver in it, and most boxes come with it or offer it as an upgrade. Umaki, uzaku and kimoyaki are the starters; at Atsuta Horaiken, umaki is ¥1,200, uzaku ¥750 and eel-bone crackers, hone senbei, ¥400. Those crackers are fried spines, salty and crisp, and the best bar snack an eel house sells.

A bowl of kimosui, clear soup with eel liver, served alongside an eel box
Kimosui, liver soup. The clear dashi carries a single curl of liver and a leaf of mitsuba. At some shops it’s a small surcharge over the plain soup, usually worth it. Photo by Zheng Zhou / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

On the table there will be a little jar of sansho, ground Japanese pepper. It has a lemony, numbing edge that cuts through the fat, and you shake a little over the eel just before you eat. People who put it on everything aren’t wrong. People who skip it are missing half the dish.

Ground Japanese sansho pepper in a jar and dish
Sansho, the eel pepper. It’s related to Sichuan pepper and has the same faint buzz on the lips. A pinch is enough; the powder loses its smell fast once a jar is open, so the fresher the better. Photo by Susan Slater / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

The conservation question

The Japanese eel is endangered. Japan’s environment ministry moved it onto its red list in 2013, and the IUCN listed it as Endangered in 2014. Because farms still depend on wild glass eels, every unagi box starts with a wild-caught fish.

Translucent glass eels, the juvenile stage of the freshwater eel
Glass eels. These are European eels, but the Japanese ones look the same: see-through, finger-length and worth a fortune by weight. Every farmed eel in Japan starts life as one of these, caught in the wild. Photo by etrusko25 / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 4.0)

The supply chain has problems. In 2025 Japan’s Fisheries Agency found that the glass-eel catch reported by the industry had been well below its own estimates for at least fourteen years. The same year, WWF Japan and researchers at Chuo University ran DNA tests on 133 kabayaki samples sold in Japan and found about 40% were American eel, not Japanese. In late 2025, an EU-led proposal to bring all eel species under international trade controls at the CITES meeting was voted down, with Japan arguing its existing regional management was enough.

Greenhouse-covered eel farm ponds in Isshiki, Nishio, Aichi Prefecture
An eel farm in Isshiki, Aichi. Isshiki is one of Japan’s big eel-farming districts, and its greenhouses look like any other farm from the road. The fish inside began as glass eels netted from the sea. Photo by HQA02330 / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

I’m not going to tell you not to eat it; I still do. But treat unagi as an occasion meal rather than a convenience food, eat it at specialists who know where their eels come from, and skip the bargain packs of unknown origin. One good box a trip, from a house that cares, is the version that makes sense.

Anago, the sea-eel cousin (and a few things to skip)

Anago is a different animal: conger eel, a saltwater fish, leaner and softer than unagi with a milder, sweeter flavour, and it belongs with the rest of the sea fish in my guide to eating fish in Japan. In Tokyo it’s usually simmered and brushed with a thick sweet sauce for sushi, or fried whole as one of the classic Edo-mae tempura pieces. On Miyajima, near Hiroshima, it’s grilled and laid over rice as anago-meshi.

Nigiri sushi topped with simmered anago sea eel
Anago nigiri. Soft enough to fall apart against the rice, with a sweet glaze called tsume. If a sushi menu says “eel” and it’s served cool and fluffy, it’s almost certainly anago. Photo by Zheng Zhou / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

A few things I’d skip:

  • Eating on Doyo no Ushi no Hi itself. Same eel, longer queue, shorter time limits at the table.
  • Vacuum-packed kabayaki of unknown origin. If the label won’t tell you the country and species, leave it.
  • Eel sushi rolls overseas called “unagi” with sticky brown sauce. Fine for what they are, but they have little to do with an eel house.
  • Hurrying. If you have forty minutes for lunch, go for a beef bowl and save eel for a day with time in it.

Pick one town, or one old Tokyo house, and give it a whole lunch. Arrive at opening, order sake and the liver skewers, and let them take as long as they like with the box.

Similar Posts